How To Spot a Republican, According to ChatGPT

Do you wear clothing with patriotic themes, listen to country music and support “traditional American values?” Well, these are some telling signs that you may be a Republican, according to AI bot ChatGPT.

Amid the 2024 Democratic National Convention, which kicked off on Monday, and the lead-up to the U.S. presidential elections in November, Newsweek asked generative AI tool ChatGPT to outline some keys ways to tell someone is a Republican.

We gave ChatGPT the following prompt: “Tell me 10 ways I might spot a Republican. In your response, please consider factors ranging from social indicators, fashion, entertainment, language use and media consumption.”

10 Signs That You’re a Republican, According to ChatGPT

Below are some points outlined by the AI tool as the markers of a Republican.

Media Consumption

Republicans “frequently watch or read conservative media outlets like Fox News, Newsmax, or The Wall Street Journal opinion section.” They may also listen to conservative talk radio or podcasts hosted by figures like Ben Shapiro or the late Rush Limbaugh, ChatGPT says.

Social Media Behavior

The social media feeds of Republicans “often feature posts or shares from conservative figures and organizations” and may “engage in discussions or share content related to Republican issues” on platforms like X, formerly Twitter, Facebook, or conservative-leaning sites like Parler or Truth Social, ChatGPT claimed.

Language and Terminology

Do you use phrases such as “pro-life,” “Second Amendment rights [the right to bear arms],” “traditional values,” “small government,” and “fiscal responsibility?” Well, Republicans use terms like these, according to the AI tool, and “their language may reflect concerns about ‘socialism’ or ‘big government.'”

“Small government” refers to a limited system where government authority is restricted by law and individual’s rights are protected against government involvement. A “big government” refers to a government that is excessively large or inefficient and more involved in regulation and public policy.

Fashion and Symbols

You might see Republicans wearing clothes or accessories with patriotic themes, such as “American flags, Make America Great Again [MAGA] hats, or camouflage,” according to ChatGPT.

“Brands like Carhartt or L.L.Bean, known for rugged, outdoor styles, might also be common,” the AI tool added.

Entertainment Preferences

Republicans also consume “conservative-leaning” entertainment, such as “country music, movies with patriotic themes, or shows that emphasize traditional family values,” ChatGPT said.

They may also follow conservative actors like Tim Allen or watch programs with “a conservative bent,” according to the AI bot.

Community and Social Activities

Republicans are often involved in community activities that align with conservative values, such as church groups, veterans’ organizations or local Republican clubs. They might also participate in or support events such as gun rights rallies or pro-life marches.

Religious Affiliation

The AI tool says that Republicans may also be affiliated with evangelical Christian or other conservative religious groups, with their religious beliefs “significantly influencing” their views on social issues like abortion, same-sex marriage and religious freedom.

Voting and Political Involvement

Republicans “consistently vote Republican in elections” and might display political yard signs, bumper stickers, or other materials supporting GOP candidates. They may also be involved in local Republican Party activities or campaigns, according to the AI tool.

Attitude Toward Government

ChatGPT says that Republicans often express support for “limited government, lower taxes, and deregulation.” They may also be critical of government spending or “express concerns about individual liberties being infringed by government policies.”

Cultural and Historical References

Republicans admire historical Republican figures, such as Ronald Reagan or Abraham Lincoln, and may “reference these figures in conversations,” according to Chat GPT.

They may also show support for “traditional American values and be critical of what they perceive as liberal cultural influences in Hollywood or mainstream media,” the AI bot says.

‘Overly Simplistic’ and Lacking ‘Nuance’

Ryan Waite is the vice president of public affairs at Think Big, an integrated marketing firm. He has worked in Republican politics for the past 20 years, creating digital strategies for various clients, including national campaigns and party committees.

Asked about ChatGPT’s markers for spotting a Republican, Waite told Newsweek: “Since large language models (LLMs) are inherently derivative, it’s not surprising that many responses tend to be stereotypical or repetitive. The nature of these models means they aggregate patterns from vast amounts of data, which often results in generic or predictable information.

For example, the observation that certain groups “consistently vote Republican” in elections “may seem obvious and lack nuance,” explained Waite, who told Newsweek, “I identify and usually vote as Republican,” although he is registered as having no party preference.

Brenda Christensen, the CEO of Stellar Public Relations, is a current PR professional for Democratic congressional candidate Madison Horn and has worked closely with “people on both sides of the aisle.”

She agreed with Waite’s thoughts, telling Newsweek that “some of the statements presented by ChatGPT are overly simplistic and are driven by LLM stereotypes. While there might be some truth to these generalizations, they don’t fully help to reveal political party affiliation.”

Citing the sentiment of a senator she once interviewed as a student political stringer for Michigan State University’s journalism school, the CEO said “a party affiliation does not overshadow a lawmaker’s voting record.”

Christensen—who has voted for both Republicans and Democrats and worked with current presidential candidate Donald Trump decades earlier as part of her role overseeing global PR for the commercial real-estate development firm The Taubman Company, among others—said that “in reality, the majority people’s political identities are down the middle and more than ever voters are not associating by political party.”

She explained: “These types of exercises only serve to divide us more and really lack the nuanced variety of factors that go beyond media consumption, fashion choices, or entertainment preferences. As someone with a minor in fashion history, I’ve observed how fashion can often signal economic trends—like how skinny ties have historically coincided with economic downturns.”

Waite argued that a more “intriguing exercise” would entail asking the AI tool to “delve into the diverse factions within the Republican Party, examining how these groups differ in ideology, priorities, and influence. This could provide a richer and more nuanced understanding of the political landscape.”

Waite warned that it is important to recognize that the perspectives generated by AI models “may not fully capture the views of right-of-center Republican voters who will decide the upcoming election.

“Understanding these nuances requires a deeper exploration beyond the surface-level patterns typically generated by AI, offering a more accurate reflection of a diverse electorate,” he said.